SandLife

Manasota Key's $29 million sand contract: $205 a day for sea turtle watching, $1 a day for shorebirds, nothing for sand fleas

Nov 13, 2026

Charlotte County's bid tabulation for the Manasota Key and South Beach Fill hurricane recovery project (bid 20260564, opened Sep 30, 2026) shows exactly what each dredging company charged for every piece of the job, including the wildlife work. Great Lakes Dredge & Dock won with the low bid of $29,103,880, approved Oct 27 (our earlier post). Here is what its bid prices for the animals:

The other three bidders priced shorebird protection at $500 a day (Weeks Marine, $65,000 total) and $2,000 a day (Callan Marine and Norfolk Dredging, $260,000 each). The bid tabulation doesn't explain the $1 figure. Contractors sometimes fold a cost into other line items, so a $1 unit price doesn't by itself prove less protection on the beach, but it does show how little of the public price is tied to the birds. For comparison, the same bid charges $12 million to mobilize the dredge and $15.20 to $19.65 a cubic yard for the sand: 590,000 cubic yards on Manasota Key and 400,000 on South Beach, which includes Englewood Beach and Stump Pass Beach State Park.

What isn't on the bid form at all: any line for the swash-zone animals. There's no item for counting sand fleas (mole crabs), coquinas or ghost crabs before or after placement, and no item for testing whether the dredged Gulf sand matches the native beach in grain size and shell content. Those are the animals sanderlings, plovers, pompano and surf fish eat, and research on our science page found mole crabs and coquinas 86 to 99% lower 5 to 10 weeks after placement on one North Carolina beach, with coarse, shelly fill suppressing coquinas for 3 to 4 years in another study.

Timing is still unsettled. The county engineer told the Englewood Sun work was estimated to start around Nov 23, pending a pre-construction meeting, and must be off the beach before sea turtle nesting starts Mar 1, 2027. The county's project page (last updated Nov 2) still lists construction from Jan 1 to Apr 30, 2027, and the contract allows 180 calendar days.

Questions for Charlotte County Public Works before sand starts moving:

  1. What does the $130 shorebird line actually buy over 130 days, and who is doing the shorebird monitoring?
  2. What is the grain size and shell content of the borrow sand compared with the native Manasota Key beach, and will those test results be published?
  3. Will anyone count mole crabs and coquinas before and after placement, next to an untouched control beach?

Full details are in the Project Tracker. Want to ask these questions yourself? Take action.

Sources