Have you noticed fewer beach birds and fewer fish to catch after the so-called wonderful beach sand replacement?

SandLife
Sanderling with an Atlantic mole crab
Sanderling with an Atlantic mole crab · Location not stated · Photo: Peter Pearsall / U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service · Public domain · credits
Long-billed curlew eating a sand crab
Long-billed curlew eating a sand crab · Morro Strand State Beach, California · Photo: Mike Baird · CC BY 2.0 · credits
Long-billed curlew with a sand crab
Long-billed curlew with a sand crab · California · Photo: Mike Baird · CC BY 2.0 · credits
Heermann's gull catching a sand crab
Heermann's gull catching a sand crab · Del Monte Beach, Monterey, California · Photo: Flanken · CC BY-SA 4.0 (share-alike) · credits
Sanderling with a mole crab (cropped)
Sanderling with a mole crab (cropped) · Fort Tilden, Queens, New York · Photo: Chelsea (iNaturalist) · CC BY · credits
Sanderling with a Pacific mole crab
Sanderling with a Pacific mole crab · Monterey County, California · Photo: Henrik Kibak (iNaturalist) · CC BY · credits

Florida's beaches · The life hidden beneath the sand

Save the hidden sand crab

Right under our feet, at the edge of every wave, lives a hidden food chain: sand crabs, coquina clams, beach hoppers and worms. They feed the shorebirds and the fish anglers chase from the surf. When a beach is rebuilt with new sand, studies in other states found these animals buried and slow to return, and few people ask what that costs.

Feature · The hidden food chain

Who lives under the sand, and who eats them

A calm-looking beach is a busy food chain. Tiny animals buried in the wet sand filter food from every wave, and bigger animals come to eat them. Take away the small ones and the hunters go hungry.

Plankton and washed-up seaweedTwo foundations of the beach food web (UC Santa Barbara)
Sand crabs, coquinas, beach hoppers, wormsFilter, scavenge and graze
Shorebirds, ghost crabs, pompano and whitingHunt the buried animals
PeopleAnglers, bird-watchers and beach-goers
An Atlantic mole crab on wet beach sand
Sand dweller

Mole crab (sand crab) Emerita talpoida

Role
Filter feeder. It backs into the wet sand tail-first and filters plankton and bits of food from each wave with feathery antennae. It is clawless, up to about 2 inches, and lives 2–3 years.
Why it matters
A primary prey base for surf fishes, ghost crabs and some shorebirds.
Threat
Mole crabs were 86–99% lower 5–10 weeks after a North Carolina sand placement. After another project there they were back by midsummer.

Sources: FWC · Peterson et al. 2000 · Peterson et al. 2006

Photo: Jinkster1313 · CC BY-SA 4.0

A pink coquina clam shell opened like butterfly wings on sand
Sand dweller

Coquina clam Donax variabilis

Role
Filter feeder in the wash zone. The colorful “butterfly” shells are the open halves of these small clams.
Why it matters
The biomass-dominant animal in one study, and a key prey for higher levels of the food web.
Threat
Coquinas stayed under 10% of normal levels from March to November on filled beaches in one North Carolina study, with no sign of recovery.

Sources: Peterson et al. 2006 · Florida ghost crab diet study (2014)

Photo: Ryan Hodnett · CC BY-SA 4.0

A beach hopper amphipod on sand
Sand dweller

Beach hopper (amphipod) Talorchestia

Role
Grazer and scavenger. It lives in damp seaweed and seagrass piles higher up the beach and feeds on them.
Why it matters
Food for shorebirds and ghost crabs. On one Florida beach, these amphipods made up about 56% of the ghost crab diet.
Threat
A different group, the swash-zone haustoriid amphipods, stayed under 10% of normal on filled North Carolina beaches. In San Diego, beach hoppers recovered within a year.

Sources: Florida ghost crab diet study (2014) · UCSB Explore Beaches · Peterson et al. 2006 · Wooldridge et al. 2016

Photo: Lythronax246 · CC BY 4.0

A bristle worm, Scolelepis squamata, against a black background
Sand dweller

Bristle worms (polychaetes) e.g. Scolelepis

Role
Small segmented worms that live in the intertidal sand.
Why it matters
Worms are part of the diet of piping plovers, along with crustaceans, insect larvae and bivalves.
Threat
Results are mixed. In North Carolina, worms bloomed on filled and unfilled beaches alike. In San Diego, worms stayed sharply reduced for the full 15 months.

Sources: USFWS · Peterson et al. 2006 · Wooldridge et al. 2016

Photo: Hans Hillewaert · CC BY-SA 4.0

An Atlantic ghost crab with large pale claws
Hunter

Ghost crab Ocypode quadrata

Role
Predator and scavenger. It digs burrows high on the beach and eats mostly mole crabs, coquinas and beach hoppers, depending on the beach.
Why it matters
An important predator on Florida beaches, and it eats the same buried animals the birds and fish depend on.
Threat
Active burrows were 55–65% lower about 3 months after beach bulldozing in North Carolina, and young crabs seemed to settle less on filled beaches.

Sources: Peterson et al. 2000 · Peterson et al. 2006 · Florida ghost crab study (PLOS ONE 2016)

Photo: George Harrison, USFWS · Public domain

A sanderling running in the wash on a Florida beach
Hunter

Shorebirds: sanderling, piping plover, red knot

Role
Hunters of the waterline. Sanderlings chase the waves to pick buried sand crabs and other small animals from the wet sand.
Why it matters
Piping plovers and rufa red knots, both federally threatened, feed on small beach animals, and USFWS counts reduced prey as an effect of sand placement.
Threat
Shorebird use, mostly sanderlings, fell 70–90% on filled North Carolina beaches until November, largely because their prey dropped.

Sources: Audubon · USFWS: piping plover · USFWS: red knot · Peterson et al. 2006

Photo: Lemic302 · CC0

A Florida pompano held in a hand over beach sand
Hunter

Pompano and whiting Trachinotus carolinus

Role
A surf fish that eats mollusks and crustaceans, “especially sand fleas,” says the FWC.
Why it matters
Prized by surf anglers, and live sand fleas are a favorite bait.
Threat
No study in Florida has measured what sand placement does to surf fish catches, so we make no claim about numbers.

Sources: FWC · UF/IFAS · Peterson et al. 2000

Photo: geosesarma (iNaturalist) · CC BY 4.0

A man surf fishing from the beach at sunset in Naples, Florida
Anglers stand at the end of this food chain. Photographed in Naples, FL. Photo: Stephen James Hall · CC0.

The research above comes from North Carolina and California, not Florida. We could not find Florida studies that count sand crabs before and after sand placement, and that is the gap SandLife wants monitoring to fill. More photos of each animal are further down this page. Read more on the food chain →

The life under the sand

Birds get counted. Their food doesn't.

Beach project permits track sea turtles, beach mice and shorebirds. The animals those birds and fish eat are rarely counted. On Florida's west (Gulf) coast that buried life includes living sand dollars, olive and moon snails, coquinas, mole crabs, worms and ghost crabs.

Our ask: count the sand dollars, snails, coquinas and crabs before and after, match the grain size, and keep work out of spring recruitment. We can save beaches and beach tourism while also protecting the food chain and the environment.

Our view · a word worth questioning

“Beach Nourishment”? These words are false marketing.

Nourishing something means feeding it. But “beach nourishment” doesn't feed the beach. It pumps or trucks in sand to hold a shoreline in place. The sand is chosen to make a wide, dry beach that looks good, protects expensive properties, offsets natural beach loss and keeps beach tourism going. The cost falls on angler tourism, fish, birds and the food chain they depend on. We can save beaches and beach tourism while also protecting the food chain and the environment.

In our opinion, for the creatures that actually live in the sand (mole crabs, coquinas, the birds and fish that eat them), a project often looks less like feeding and more like malnourishment: the food web is buried, and the replacement sand may be the wrong kind for it. “Nourishment” is a friendly name for a construction project, and a friendly name makes it harder to ask what the project costs the animals living on the beach.

This section is advocacy and opinion. The facts it rests on are cited below and in the studies table further down. We are not saying nourishment should never happen. We are saying the animals and the industries that depend on them should be counted.

One practice, many names

Agencies and contracts use different words for the same kind of project:

  • Beach nourishment: the common term, used by FDEP and the Corps.
  • Renourishment: repeat placements to replace sand that has washed away; the Corps says fill must be added periodically (USACE SPBA).
  • Beach fill: sand “placed on the shoreline by mechanical means,” by dredge and pump or by truck (USACE SPBA).
  • Replenishment: the term used by New Jersey's DEP (NJDEP; CTC-N).
  • Also: beach restoration, shore protection, sand placement and coastal storm risk management (see the tracker).

What it does well

  • Tourism. A wide beach keeps visitors coming. FDEP calls Florida's beaches a primary attraction for almost 19 million tourists a year (FDEP).
  • Property and infrastructure. Engineered beaches and dunes are designed to absorb storm energy before it reaches buildings and roads (NJDEP; USACE).
  • Recreation space. The Corps says the resulting beach is also “a valuable recreational resource.”

What it can cost

  • The food web. Studies found mole crabs and coquinas buried and slow to recover, especially after wrong-sized sand or poor timing (Peterson 2000; Peterson 2006).
  • Shorebirds. Fewer sand-dwelling prey means less food for sanderlings, plovers and red knots (see the food web above and the studies table below).
  • Surf fishing. Pompano and whiting eat sand fleas, so fishing could suffer too. No Florida study measures this yet, and we claim no number.

Fair is fair: it's a trade-off. Tourism and property protection are real benefits, and some studies show certain animals bounce back within a year or so. The harm depends on sand quality, grain size and timing. Our ask is simple: match the sand to the beach, avoid the worst seasons, and count the animals before and after.

Featured creature

The sand flea, also called the Atlantic mole crab

Emerita talpoida isn't a flea and doesn't bite. It's a small, clawless crab, up to about 2 inches long, that lives in the swash zone, where waves wash up the beach (FWC).

It backs into the wet sand with its tail first and holds up two feathery antennae. Each wave brings plankton and bits of food, and the crab filters them out. Then it digs in again before the water pulls it away. Anglers call it a sand flea, and it's one of the best-known baits for pompano (UF/IFAS Extension).

Why it matters: it turns plankton into a bite-size meal. In the research below, mole crabs and coquinas are described as a primary prey base for surf fishes, ghost crabs and some shorebirds (Peterson et al. 2000). The FWC says Florida pompano feed on mollusks and crustaceans, “especially sand fleas” (FWC).

An Atlantic mole crab on wet beach sand
A live mole crab on a beach on Long Island, New York. Photo: Jinkster1313 · CC BY-SA 4.0.
Side view of a preserved Atlantic mole crab specimen against a black background
A preserved specimen shows the paddle-like legs and short tail it digs with. Photo: Eric A. Lazo-Wasem / Yale Peabody Museum · CC0.

Life cycle of a mole crab

Eggs. Females carry orange eggs under the body, and are the bigger sex, up to about 2 inches; males stay under an inch (Mitchell's Publications; Florida Sportsman).
Drifting larvae. The young hatch into the plankton and pass through several larval stages before settling. In one lab study, this took about four weeks (larval development study).
Settling. Young crabs settle onto the beach, and new recruits arrive mostly in the warm months. That is one reason the timing of sand placement matters (Peterson et al. 2006).
Adults. They ride the tides up and down the beach, filter plankton, and live only two to three years (FWC).

Mole crabs can recover quickly. In one North Carolina study they were back by mid-summer, while coquinas and tiny amphipods on the same beaches stayed below 10% of normal levels the whole season (Peterson et al. 2006). Each species responds differently, which is why monitoring should count all of them.

The beach food web

Who eats what lives in the sand

A beach that looks empty is a feeding ground. Shorebirds run the waterline for buried crabs and clams. Fish patrol the surf just offshore for the same food. Ghost crabs hunt by night.

Birds

A sanderling standing in shallow water on a Florida beach

Sanderling

Chases receding waves to find sand crabs and other beach invertebrates buried in the wet sand. Winters on Florida beaches.

Audubon · shorebird use fell 70–90% on filled beaches (Peterson 2006)

Photo: Lemic302 · CC0

A willet resting on one leg on a Florida beach

Willet

Winter visitors feed in the swash zone on mole crabs and coquina clams. On the coast they also eat many other crabs and small mollusks.

Apalachicola Riverkeeper · Audubon

Photo: patriciafarrell89 · CC BY 2.0

A ruddy turnstone standing on beach sand

Ruddy turnstone

Flips over shells and seaweed to find crustaceans, mollusks and worms along the shore.

Audubon

Photographed in Brooklyn, NY. Photo: Rhododendrites · CC BY-SA 4.0

A piping plover on wet sand with seaweed at Smyrna Dunes Park, Florida
Federally threatened

Piping plover

Winters on Florida's beaches, where it forages on the intertidal beach for worms, crustaceans, insect larvae and bivalves. USFWS counts reduced prey as an effect of sand placement.

USFWS species page · USFWS 2013 programmatic opinion

Photographed at Smyrna Dunes Park, FL. Photo: Andrea Westmoreland · CC BY-SA 2.0

A rufa red knot in orange breeding plumage standing in surf
Federally threatened

Rufa red knot

A long-distance migrant listed as threatened in 2014. It feeds on small clams, mussels and crustaceans, and nourishment can reduce that prey.

USFWS species page · Federal Register listing

Photographed on Delaware Bay, NJ. Photo: Chuck Homler / Focus On Wildlife · CC BY-SA 4.0

A laughing gull standing on a Florida beach

Gulls

Laughing gulls eat small fish, crustaceans and insects on beaches and are listed among mole-crab predators.

Audubon · Mitchell's Publications

Photographed at Daytona Beach, FL. Photo: VJAnderson · CC BY-SA 4.0

Fish and surf fishing

A Florida pompano held in a hand over beach sand

Florida pompano

A prized surf fish. The FWC says it feeds on mollusks and crustaceans, especially sand fleas. Live sand fleas are a favorite bait.

FWC · UF/IFAS

Photo: geosesarma (iNaturalist) · CC BY 4.0

A southern kingfish lying on a wooden surface

Whiting (kingfish)

Whiting and kingfish (Menticirrhus) are among the fish anglers catch on sand fleas from the surf.

Florida Sportsman

Southern kingfish, photographed in Brazil. Photo: Cláudio D. Timm · CC BY 2.0

A red drum, also called redfish

Redfish (red drum)

Sand fleas are a favorite food of larger animals, including pompano, redfish and shorebirds.

UF/IFAS Extension

Photo: Raver Duane, USFWS · Public domain

A person fishing from a beach in Naples, Florida at sunset

Surf fishing

Fishing from the beach is part of Florida's recreational saltwater fishing, which the FWC estimates at $7.4 billion in economic contribution and 47,301 jobs (2022 activity; all saltwater anglers, not only surf).

FWC programs report

Naples, FL. Photo: Stephen James Hall · CC0

Other sand animals

An Atlantic ghost crab with large pale claws on beach vegetation

Atlantic ghost crab

Digs burrows high on the beach and hunts at night. In North Carolina, active ghost crab burrows were 55–65% lower about 3 months after bulldozing for dune building, and crab recruitment looked reduced on filled beaches.

Peterson et al. 2000 · Peterson et al. 2006

Photo: George Harrison, USFWS · Public domain

A pink coquina clam shell opened like butterfly wings

Coquina clam

The colorful “butterfly” shells are tiny clams that live in the surf zone. In one study Donax was the biomass-dominant animal and a key prey for higher levels of the food web.

Peterson et al. 2006

Barefoot Beach, Collier County, FL. Photo: Ryan Hodnett · CC BY-SA 4.0

The hidden danger

Rebuilding a beach can bury the food web beneath it

Beach renourishment (also called replenishment or “sand placement”) pumps or trucks in sand to widen an eroding beach. It protects property and keeps beaches open for visitors, and Florida's FY2026-27 state funding request list alone totals $336,198,762 in beach project costs. What it does to the animals living in the sand is rarely checked.

The Florida Department of Environmental Protection describes beaches as a primary attraction for almost 19 million tourists a year (FDEP). Our concern is the part nobody counts: the crabs, clams and worms that make a beach work as a feeding ground.

A hopper dredge offshore and a bulldozer pushing a discharge pipe on a beach during renourishment
Sand pumped onto a beach during a renourishment in Sandbridge, Virginia (not Florida). Photo: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers · Public domain.

How it hurts

Buried. New sand is placed on the beach in huge volumes. The animals in the swash zone are covered or displaced while the beach is being built.
Wrong sand. Fill that is finer, coarser or shellier than the native beach has been linked to the worst losses. The NC fill had far more shell hash than the native sand (Peterson et al. 2000).
Slow return. Depending on the fill and the season, studies found recovery in about a year for some animals, and 2–4 years for others.
Knock-on effects. Fewer prey means fewer birds feeding on the beach, and less food for surf fish.
A bulldozer working on a beach crowded with gulls during renourishment
Heavy equipment on a renourished beach in Virginia Beach, Virginia (not Florida). Photo: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers · Public domain.

What it can mean for birds, fishing and tourism

  • Birds: In the 2006 North Carolina study, shorebird use fell 70–90% on filled beaches. Piping plovers and red knots, both federally threatened, winter on Florida beaches.
  • Fishing: Mole crabs and coquinas are described as a primary prey base for surf fishes, and sand fleas are standard bait. Florida recreational saltwater fishing contributes an estimated $7.4 billion a year.
  • Tourism: Beaches draw almost 19 million visitors a year. Birdwatching, shelling and surf fishing are part of what they come for.

What we don't know: we found no published study that measures how many fish are lost, or how many visitors are lost, because beach invertebrates were buried in Florida. We are not claiming a figure. The studies show lost prey and fewer shorebirds. The fishing and tourism consequences are why monitoring is needed, and why we are asking for it. Nourishment can also help beaches and property, and not every project has the same impact. What matters is how well the fill matches the native sand, and when it is placed.

What the studies found

StudyWhereWhat was found
Peterson, Hickerson & Johnson 2000Bogue Banks, North CarolinaFill was much finer than the native sand and full of shell hash. Mole crabs and coquinas were 86–99% lower 5–10 weeks later. Ghost crab burrows were 55–65% lower after bulldozing.
Peterson et al. 2006Bogue Banks, North CarolinaCoarse winter fill cut the usable intertidal beach by 14–29%. Coquinas and tiny amphipods stayed under 10% of control levels, with no recovery from March to November. Shorebird use (mostly sanderlings) fell 70–90%. Mole crabs recovered by mid-summer.
Peterson et al. 2014North CarolinaAfter two coarse, shelly fills, coquinas and amphipods stayed low for 3–4 years, ghost crabs for up to 4 summers, and foraging shorebirds for 2–4 years.
Rakocinski et al. 1996Perdido Key, FloridaOn 7 km of restored shoreline, species richness and total density fell. Effects of silt and clay loading offshore were still evident more than 2 years later.
Wooldridge, Henter & Kohn 2016San Diego County, CaliforniaNearly all animals declined right after replenishment at 8 beaches. Sand-hopper amphipods and bean clams recovered within a year, and mole crabs bloomed after 4 months and then evened out. Worms stayed down through 15 months, leaving total invertebrates more than twofold lower.
Hubbard, Dugan et al. 2014Southern CaliforniaNot a nourishment study. Two upper-beach isopod species disappeared from 16 and 14 historic sites (57% and 64% declines). They survive mostly on remote, ungroomed, unarmored beaches.
Dugan et al. 2003Southern CaliforniaBeach grooming reduced beach animals and the prey available to shorebirds. Two plover species were more numerous where kelp wrack and the invertebrates in it were more plentiful.
Peterson & Bishop 2005Review of 46 monitoring studiesOnly 11% controlled for natural variation and 56% reached conclusions not adequately supported. Monitoring is usually run through project promoters, and results are rarely used to set mitigation.

Why almost no one knows

Florida requires fill to meet a beach-compatibility rule on grain size, shell and silt (Rule 62B-41.007(2)(j)). The federal opinion that governs most Florida sand placement focuses on sea turtles, beach mice and shorebirds. In the permit documents we reviewed, we found no routine requirement to count mole crabs or coquinas (USFWS 2015 statewide opinion). Peterson and Bishop reviewed 46 monitoring studies and criticized how monitoring is designed and used (2005 review).

Follow the sand

Florida's beach projects, tracked

We keep a public tracker of Florida beach sand placement projects, with cost, contractor and sand source where it is published, and a link to the source for each record.

59
Florida sand placement projects & contracts tracked (2023–2027)
$336,198,762
Beach projects in Florida's FY2026-27 state funding request list (FDEP)
$624,552,856
in beach-fill contract awards we could document

Help us protect the life beneath the sand

Seen sand trucks, a dredge pipe or bulldozers on your beach? Tell us. Want to count sand fleas or help with permit comments? Get in touch.

SandLife is a nonprofit in formation and is not yet tax-exempt. Photo: 4net · CC BY 3.0 · credits